Atwt great storyline idea

[carjacker]

I really don't want Carjack with other people and still want Skatie but what about this

Simon and Carly start seeing eachother both trying to make Katie and Jack jelaous but it backfire and Katie and Jack start seeing eachother which cause Simon and Carly to be jeloaus.So they go around and around trying to out do eachother.That could be fun but the only problem is Mike is in the way.

Where can Mike fit in at :D

[Lavender]

Had Jack not had three serious love affairs since he met Carly, and had Carly not begged and groveled during those times, then yeah, it would be a cute story. But because Jack has had those very serious relationships (and a marriage when Carly was BEGGING him to love her!), he needs to see Carly in one so HE can learn HIS lesson. He's had to choose either Carly or one of his Julia's since the day they met. It doesn't matter to me that he chose Carly in the end, he still had to choose while she listened to him tell her he loved another woman...three times. . Let's have Carly in this position for a change. Carly needs to feel special, I'm TIRED of watching her hunched over afraid of her own shadow when Jack starts screaming at her or berating her.

[carjacker]

Lavender when did Jack have 3 love affairs.

I remember when he first met Julia but Carly ws married to Hal and wanted to stay with Hal so Jack left and that's how he met First Julia.

Then Carly left him at the altar and that's when he got back with Julia #1

Only affair I ever saw was with Julia#2 and that was when he had amnseia.


I miss out on the love affairs for Jack unless you count Mitzi but they was broken up and Carly was with Craig.


As where Carly had Hal,Brad,Craig and then Mike again. The wasn't love afairs but she was sexual invlove with them.

[Lavender]

I'm not begrudging Jack for hooking up with Julia the first time, Carly was married to Hal. But afterwards, Jack did talk to Emma and he actually asked her advice on who to CHOOSE between the two women. lol. Plus, Jack was seriously in love with Julia, no doubt about it, even though he still loved Carly. Serious Relationship Number One.

After Carly "left Jack at the altar", she came home from a kidnapping which saved Jack and Parker's lives. Carly told him the whole story of what happened to her before she met him, that going to prison in HK, marrying Lowe to get out, NOT having sex with Lowe, seeing an attorney who told her the marriage was probably invalid, so she didn't think she was married to Lowe. When Jack heard the story (and it was a sad one too, I thought he'd take her in his arms, no kidding), he manhandled her, then went and PROPOSED to Julia, then proceeded to marry her. While Carly was homeless and begging him to love her. Serious Relationship Number Two.

Julia and JJ. 'Nuff said.

So Carly had to listen to Jack tell her he loved another woman three different times (and many many times at that) since they met, and he was damn serious about these women too. Carly has never returned the favor to Jack. It's high time she did. ;)

[carjacker]

To me Jack never really love Julia #2 but he came to love Jj I don't urgue with that. But Julia#1 is a difrent story.

Jack was intitle to fall in love with Julai #1 because Carly left and to him she didn't want him. I will put Hal and Julia #1 together .They meant diffrent things to Carjack. In her own way Carly did love Hal and she told him so and she even told Jack so. Basicaly she through it in Jack face that's why he left and meet up with Julia #1.

When she left him at the alter Julia came back around and I would say that time she was rebound just like Brad and Craig was rebound for her when Jack broke up with her.

Julia #2 is a diffrent story. :rofl:

[Lavender]

I miss out on the love affairs for Jack unless you count Mitzi but they was broken up and Carly was with Craig.

Uh, yeah, they were broken up because Jack was MARRIED to Julia!!!!!!! And Carly and Craig had all of a one month "affair" and not once did she tell him she loved him, and she never told Jack she loved Craig. She was hoping Jack would come back to her during that time.

As where Carly had Hal,Brad,Craig and then Mike again. The wasn't love afairs but she was sexual invlove with them.

Carly had sex with Hal because she was trying to get the money for her unborn child. Brad BLACKMAILED her and she had sex with him one time so she could get out of the marriage. Craig....Jack was MARRIED. Mike, it was a one night stand because Jack dumped her. We've seen Jack have sex hundreds of times with other women outside of Carly. We've seen Carly have sex maybe 4 times. :D The thing is, Jack has fallen in love THREE times with other women since he met Carly. Carly never has. THIS is what I'm talking about.

[TRose]

No I don't have any interest in Carly using Simon or anyone else to make Jack jealous. I want Carly to stand by what she recently told Jack that his kind of love (post amnesia) is not good for her. Then I want Carly to get on with her life and if she falls for another guy I want it to be because she has truly fallen for someone else. If the guy turns out to be Simon, great . I have even less interest in Katie and Jack hooking up to make Simon or Carly jealous. That type of contrived plot never works for me. As for Mike when it comes to Katie, he isn't the one in the way, Simon is.

[dustyfan1xxluvu]

I really don't want Carjack with other people and still want Skatie but what about this

Simon and Carly start seeing eachother both trying to make Katie and Jack jelaous but it backfire and Katie and Jack start seeing eachother which cause Simon and Carly to be jeloaus.So they go around and around trying to out do eachother.That could be fun but the only problem is Mike is in the way.

Where can Mike fit in at :D\


KEEP MATIE!!!!!!!!!!!:D :D :D

[Lavender]

When she left him at the alter Julia came back around and I would say that time she was rebound just like Brad and Craig was rebound for her when Jack broke up with her.

How did you come up with Brad and Craig being rebound for Carly?

Brad blackmailed Carly into marriage because he knew about the paternity. She didn't love OR even like the guy. Then he blackmailed her into having sex with him one time and he'd grant her a divorce, which she did. He was hoping she'd fall in love with him, but she merely had sex with him then they divorced. That was not rebound. She loathed the guy.

Jack threw Carly away like yesterday's garbage when she came home from her kidnapping and she was rendered homeless. Craig was the only person who gave her a place to live while Jack went out and married Julia. It was almost a year later that Carly and Craig had that very short affair. Jack pushed Carly into Craig's orbit because of how he'd constantly defend Julia and hide her CRIMES. Plus, Jack was married. lol

To this day I firmly believe Jack loved Julia #2. If he didn't, then why did he get his memory back and tell Carly he had to go HOME to Julia? Why then did Carly have to beg Jack to make love to her and he wouldn't, but he came very close to making love with Julia? And why then did he have to CHOOSE between Carly and Julia? If it was only about JJ, then Jack made it abundantly clear he loved JJ more than Sage for even considering which family he wanted to be with. Jack actually having to choose spoke volumes to me.

[Ms. Tee 7]

No I don't have any interest in Carly using Simon or anyone else to make Jack jealous. I want Carly to stand by what she recently told Jack that his kind of love (post amnesia) is not good for her. Then I want Carly to get on with her life and if she falls for another guy I want it to be because she has truly fallen for someone else. If the guy turns out to be Simon, great . I have even less interest in Katie and Jack hooking up to make Simon or Carly jealous. That type of contrived plot never works for me. As for Mike when it comes to Katie, he isn't the one in the way, Simon is.ITA. It's time for Carly to do something for just Carly. Every move she makes has been about Jack for far too long. I'd like to see her in a relationship with someone else and it have nothing to do with Jack! I want Carly to be a strong woman again... one that does not need to beg Jack to love her. It's time that she got over Jack and got on with her life.